Application Review Criteria

When reviewing applications, we look for signs of efficient and effective organizations. We recognize that not every organization will meet all of our criteria. The criteria are meant as a general guide, not a definitive checklist. We believe there are many models of successful nonprofit organizations and are interested in learning about how you have been successful.

Grant application reviews consider the following:

1. Leadership. Does your project offer an opportunity to develop community leadership or expand civic involvement?
2. Purpose. Does your project reflect the purpose of the grant program for which you are applying?
3. Impact. To what extent might your project make a lasting and significant difference in the quality of life for San Juan Islanders?
4. Strategy. Does your project address current or emerging community needs or opportunities?
5. Capacity. Does your organization have the resources and leadership to ensure project success?
6. Leverage. Can you show that additional funds, partners etc… are (or have been) involved?
7. Inclusiveness. Are any underserved segments of the community reached by your proposal? Is diversity promoted? How are the stakeholders for this project included?
8. Goals. Can you explain what ‘success’ will look like and how will it be measured?
9. Design. Is your project designed in a clear, thoughtful, reasonable manner?

Occasionally there may be interviews with the applicant’s staff/board and a site visit.